Story by Joel Berly
July 18, 2025
If you’re involved in a personal injury case, avoiding mistakes is key to getting fair compensation. Missteps like delaying medical care or accepting a low settlement can cost you thousands. Here’s what you need to know:
These six mistakes can significantly impact your case. Acting quickly, documenting everything, and consulting an attorney can help secure the compensation you deserve.
One of the most common missteps accident victims make is putting off medical treatment. This delay can not only jeopardize your health but also weaken your personal injury claim.
Why getting care immediately is critical:
After an accident, adrenaline and shock can mask the pain or symptoms of injuries. Conditions like concussions, internal bleeding, or soft tissue damage might not show obvious signs right away. Ignoring or delaying treatment could allow these injuries to worsen without you even realizing it.
"Getting medical care immediately after your accident is one of the most important steps you can take. It can change the course of your recovery and directly affect the outcome of your personal injury claim."
Insurance companies often seize on any delay in treatment, arguing that gaps in your medical care mean your injuries aren’t as serious as you claim. In fact, data shows that settlements tend to be about 30% higher for people who seek treatment immediately after an accident.
Medical records are a key piece of evidence in personal injury cases. They establish a clear timeline linking your injuries directly to the accident. Without a prompt medical evaluation, injuries could go undocumented, leaving your case vulnerable. For instance, in 2024, 37% of rideshare accidents in South Carolina involved delayed injury symptoms.
Seeking immediate care not only helps prevent complications but also ensures all injuries are documented for future medical costs. This documentation plays a critical role in protecting your claim from being undervalued.
No matter how you feel after an accident, it’s essential to get checked out by a medical professional. Visit an emergency room, urgent care center, or your primary doctor within 24 hours. Be completely honest about all your symptoms – big or small – and follow every treatment plan or recommendation. Thorough documentation of your injuries can make a significant difference in your case.
While accurate and timely medical records are the foundation of your claim, documenting the accident itself is just as important. Proper accident documentation will further strengthen your case.
Failing to document an accident properly can seriously weaken your personal injury claim. In the chaos following an accident, it’s easy to miss critical details, but these oversights can limit your compensation.
The first step in effective documentation is ensuring accurate external records. For example, insurance adjusters often depend heavily on police reports when evaluating claims and negotiating settlements. If these reports are incomplete or contain errors, proving what happened becomes much harder. Mistakes in the report could wrongly assign blame, and missing details might disrupt the timeline or fail to connect the accident to your injuries.
At the scene, use your smartphone to capture as much evidence as possible. Take photos or videos of vehicle damage, road conditions (like skid marks or traffic signs), weather, visible injuries, and license plates. Visual evidence is far more reliable than memory, especially as time passes.
Be sure to collect key details from everyone involved. This includes names, contact information, driver’s license and insurance numbers, as well as the make, model, and year of the vehicles. Don’t forget to note the time, location, and the names and badge numbers of the responding officers.
Witness accounts can also play a crucial role. If there are witnesses, gather their names and contact information. If possible, ask them for a brief written statement while the incident is still fresh in their minds. This can provide an unbiased account of what happened and strengthen your case.
To stay organized, use your phone to jot down notes, sketch the accident scene, and save all related photos, videos, and documents in one dedicated folder. This way, everything you need is in one place.
After the accident, review the police report as soon as it’s available. If you spot any factual errors, contact the officer who filed it to request a correction. Additionally, keep track of all expenses related to the accident – like medical bills or repair costs – and document every piece of communication about your case.
Thorough and timely documentation isn’t just helpful – it’s essential. It strengthens your claim and ensures you’re prepared to handle any challenges that come your way.
Saying the wrong thing or admitting fault after an accident can seriously hurt your chances of getting fair compensation.
Even a simple apology like "I’m sorry" can be twisted into an admission of guilt. Insurance companies may use this against you to reduce or deny your claim entirely. In South Carolina, where the comparative negligence system is used, your compensation can decrease if you’re found even partially at fault. For example, if you’re deemed 30% responsible, your payout could be reduced by 30%. In states like North Carolina, which follow contributory negligence rules, being even 1% at fault might mean you can’t recover anything at all. Plus, any initial statement you make may be treated as final and unchangeable later on.
Insurance adjusters are not on your side – they work for the insurance company, and their job is to minimize how much they pay out. They might call you soon after the accident, knowing you’re likely still shaken and vulnerable, hoping to catch you off guard. Anything you say during these conversations can be recorded and later used to reduce or deny your claim. This is why having a lawyer on your side from the start is so important.
Getting legal advice before you talk to the insurance company is critical. As one legal expert explains:
"Consulting an attorney before speaking with insurance companies may be in your best interest after an injury due to the negligence of another person." – McDuffey & Medcalf LLC
An experienced attorney knows how to handle these conversations to protect your rights. They can ensure that insurance companies only get the information they’re entitled to, and they’ll negotiate on your behalf to secure a fair settlement. This allows you to focus on recovering from your injuries while your lawyer handles the complex legal and insurance processes.
To safeguard your claim, take these steps instead of speaking freely:
Avoid signing any documents or accepting settlements without legal advice. A personal injury attorney can review offers to ensure they’re fair and guide you through the claims process, helping you secure the compensation you deserve.
When dealing with insurance claims, it’s crucial to avoid common pitfalls that could weaken your case. One of the biggest mistakes? Accepting the first settlement offer.
Insurance companies often take advantage of victims’ stress and financial strain by presenting quick, lowball offers. These offers might seem tempting in the moment, but they rarely reflect the true value of your claim.
Insurance companies are in the business of making profits, not prioritizing your recovery. As The Hadi Law Firm explains:
"That first offer is almost always a lowball… Insurance companies are profit-driven. Their goal? Pay you the least amount possible. They count on you being overwhelmed, uninformed, or desperate for cash."
These offers typically fail to consider the full extent of your damages, such as long-term medical care, physical therapy, future lost wages, or emotional pain and suffering. Some injuries, like concussions or spinal issues, may take weeks to fully manifest – but insurers won’t wait for the complete picture before making their move.
Agreeing to a first offer means forfeiting your right to seek additional compensation later. This decision can have serious financial consequences. Maronick Law LLC warns:
"In many cases, saying yes too soon could be a $50,000 mistake – or more."
Statistics back this up: accident victims with legal representation receive, on average, 3.5 times more in settlements than those without a lawyer. That’s a significant difference, highlighting how much money people lose when they settle too quickly.
Insurance adjusters often create a sense of urgency, labeling their offers as "time-sensitive" or discouraging you from seeking legal help by claiming it will delay your payout. They rely on your financial worries and lack of legal knowledge to push you into an early decision.
Lawrence & Associates Accident and Injury Lawyers, LLC sums it up well:
"The first settlement offer from an insurance company is rarely in your best interest. It’s designed to minimize the insurer’s payout, not fully compensate you."
To protect yourself and ensure fair compensation, follow these steps:
Wallace Pierce Law offers this critical advice:
"Accepting the first offer is often a mistake – and can end up costing you thousands of dollars in lost compensation."
Taking the time to evaluate your claim thoroughly and negotiate from a position of knowledge and strength will almost always lead to a better outcome than rushing into a low initial offer.
Evidence is the foundation of any personal injury claim. Yet, many accident victims make the mistake of not collecting, preserving, or presenting it properly. Without strong evidence, the chances of securing fair compensation drop significantly – or disappear entirely.
Gathering evidence is a critical part of building a solid case. It’s how you demonstrate the severity of your injuries and prove the other party’s fault. Without it, your claim becomes harder to argue, which could drastically reduce the compensation you receive. Beyond documenting the accident scene and seeking immediate medical care, keeping detailed records and evidence is essential to strengthening your claim.
In South Carolina, the stakes are especially high because of the state’s modified comparative negligence rule. This law only allows you to recover damages if you’re less than 51% at fault for the accident. The stronger your evidence, the better your chances of proving the other party holds greater responsibility. To put things in perspective, consider this: in 2022, South Carolina saw over 140,000 traffic collisions, leading to 1,080 fatalities. Charleston County alone accounted for more than 14,000 crashes. If you’re seeking compensation for medical bills, lost wages, or other expenses, strong evidence can make all the difference.
In personal injury cases, evidence generally falls into four categories:
Even with the best intentions, it’s easy to make mistakes that could weaken your case. One common error is neglecting to write down your personal account of the incident right away. Memory fades quickly, and the vivid details you recall immediately after the accident may become blurry within days, weakening your testimony.
Another frequent misstep is inadequate photo documentation. Snapping just one or two photos isn’t enough. You should capture the accident scene, your injuries, and any property damage from multiple angles. This comprehensive visual evidence can significantly bolster your claim.
Collecting evidence is only part of the process. How you store and organize it is just as important. Keep backups of all evidence, both physically and digitally. Use cloud storage platforms with encryption and regular backups to safeguard digital files. For physical evidence, store items in a safe, controlled environment to prevent damage or deterioration. Don’t overlook communication records – save copies of emails, letters, and text messages related to your incident, as these can also strengthen your case.
Once you’ve documented your accident and injuries, sticking to your medical treatment plan is just as important. Ignoring or delaying treatment – or failing to follow your doctor’s advice – can seriously harm your claim. Insurance companies are quick to interpret missed appointments or unfilled prescriptions as signs that your injuries aren’t as severe as you claim. This could lead to reduced compensation or even a complete denial of your claim.
For example, insurers often comb through medical records to find skipped therapy sessions, missed follow-ups, or prescriptions that were never filled. These gaps can be used to argue that your injuries don’t warrant the compensation you’re seeking. On the other hand, consistent treatment demonstrates both the seriousness of your injuries and your commitment to recovery. Interestingly, nearly 80% of doctors report that patients frequently abandon recommended treatments because of insurance delays, yet over one-third of initially denied claims are eventually overturned.
To strengthen your case, keep detailed records of every medical appointment, treatment, and prescription. This not only helps document the impact of your injuries on your daily life but also captures related expenses, such as transportation costs.
Follow your treatment plan to the letter: attend every scheduled appointment, take your medications as prescribed, and promptly report any changes in your condition. Doing so not only aids your recovery but also creates a solid medical history that can significantly bolster your personal injury claim.
The choices you make after an accident can have a major impact on your settlement. Below is a breakdown of common mistakes and how avoiding them can strengthen your claim:
| Mistake | Making the Mistake | Avoiding the Mistake |
|---|---|---|
| Not Getting Medical Care Right Away | Insurance companies may argue your injuries aren’t serious or weren’t caused by the accident, which could weaken your claim. | Getting medical care promptly creates a clear connection between the accident and your injuries, helps prevent complications, and aligns with most insurance policies requiring treatment within a week. |
| Poor Accident Documentation | Without proper documentation, proving liability becomes harder, which can reduce your compensation or even dismiss your case. | Collecting thorough evidence – like photos, witness statements, and medical records – builds a strong case and provides clear proof of liability. |
| Admitting Fault or Speaking Without Legal Help | Statements made without legal advice can be used against you. Insurance adjusters may twist your words to lower their liability and reduce your compensation. | Avoiding fault admission and letting your attorney handle communication protects your rights and ensures your case is accurately presented. |
| Taking the First Low Settlement Offer | Early settlement offers often fail to cover future expenses and may result in forfeiting additional compensation. | Consulting a lawyer can help you negotiate for a higher settlement – sometimes up to three times more than what you might secure alone. |
| Not Keeping or Showing Evidence | Lack of evidence makes it harder to prove damages and negligence, weakening your claim. | Keeping detailed records bolsters your case and ensures accurate calculation of both economic and non-economic damages. |
| Skipping Medical Treatment or Doctor’s Orders | Ignoring recommended treatments can make it seem like your injuries aren’t serious, weakening the connection between the accident and your condition. | Following all medical advice and attending appointments shows the seriousness of your injuries and creates a strong medical record to support your claim. |
These examples illustrate how even small missteps can have big financial consequences. For instance, one attorney successfully negotiated a settlement nine times higher than the initial lowball offer by challenging it.
The bottom line? Every decision you make – from seeking immediate medical attention to documenting everything – can either strengthen or weaken your case. By understanding these potential pitfalls, you can protect your rights and work toward the best possible recovery.
Navigating personal injury claims can be challenging, but avoiding the six common mistakes discussed here can significantly improve your chances of protecting your rights and securing fair compensation. From seeking prompt medical attention to thoroughly documenting your accident, each step plays a critical role in shaping the outcome of your case.
The stakes are considerable. Hiring a personal injury lawyer could increase your settlement by thousands of dollars. Avoiding these missteps can make a noticeable difference in the final compensation you receive.
In South Carolina, the law gives you three years to file a personal injury lawsuit. Delaying action can weaken your case, as evidence may become harder to collect and the link between your injuries and the accident may be harder to establish. This time limit highlights the importance of acting promptly and seeking professional guidance early on.
Experienced legal professionals, like the team at Berly Rouse Attorneys, can help you steer clear of these pitfalls. They ensure your claim accurately reflects the full extent of your injuries and losses, giving you the best chance for a successful outcome.
Additionally, many personal injury attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you only pay if they win your case. This arrangement allows you to access expert legal representation without upfront financial stress.
Take control of your recovery and ensure you receive the compensation you deserve. Contact Berly Rouse Attorneys today for a free consultation and start building a strong case for your claim.
Admitting fault right after an accident can seriously damage your chances of a successful personal injury claim. Even if you think you might share some responsibility, your words could be twisted or used against you later by insurance companies or in court.
The best approach is to let the investigation determine who’s at fault. Instead of talking about blame, prioritize safety – make sure everyone is okay, get medical help if needed, and focus on collecting key evidence. Take photos, gather witness details, and obtain a copy of the police report. Staying calm and avoiding unnecessary statements can go a long way in protecting your rights.
Hiring a personal injury lawyer can make a huge difference in the success of your claim. They have the legal expertise to navigate complicated laws, safeguard your rights, and help you steer clear of costly errors. Plus, they manage negotiations with insurance companies, ensuring you don’t feel pressured into accepting a settlement that’s less than you deserve.
On top of that, they take care of collecting essential evidence – like medical records, accident reports, and witness statements – to build a solid case. This allows you to focus on your recovery while they work to secure the highest possible compensation and the best outcome for your situation.
When an insurance company presents its first settlement offer, it’s tempting to accept and move on. But doing so can be risky – it often doesn’t account for the full scope of your damages or future expenses. Insurance companies typically aim to settle claims quickly and at the lowest possible cost, which means their initial offer might undervalue what you’re truly owed.
Accepting too soon could leave you without compensation for unexpected medical bills, long-term injuries, or other damages that surface later. That’s why it’s crucial to take the time to thoroughly review the offer and seek advice from a legal professional. This ensures your rights are upheld and you receive a settlement that accurately reflects the true value of your claim.
If you need experienced legal representation in Charleston, South Carolina, contact Berly Rouse. Our team is ready to help you achieve the best possible outcome. Visit our offices or call today to schedule a consultation to discuss your case.
At Berly Rouse, we’re proud to be a leading law firm in Charleston, SC, committed to serving our community with integrity, dedication, and legal excellence. Let us put our experience to work for you.
© 2025 Berly Rouse Attorneys at Law. All Rights Reserved.
